Blog · SEO and AI search

What to Ask Before Hiring an SEO or Marketing Agency

Ask any agency to show you what it will do, what it will report and what you can take with you if you leave. Walk away from promises of a number one ranking or from methods it will not explain. Make sure you own your accounts and data. Google says no one can guarantee a top ranking.

Start by asking whether you need an agency

Google's own page on this topic, Do you need an SEO?, says small local businesses can often do much of the work themselves. It suggests starting with Google's SEO Starter Guide, so you can spot advice that Google does not recommend. It also says hiring is most useful during a redesign or a new launch, and that a good SEO can still improve an existing site.

An agency saves you time and brings experience. It cannot buy you a place in Google's results: Google says it does not take money to include or rank sites in organic results. If your budget is tight, our article on Google Ads or local SEO first covers which channel to try first. A good site also helps, and the small business website checklist shows what to have in place.

This article is general information, not legal advice. Terms and policies can change, so check the current version of each source linked here.

Red flags to walk away from

Google's guide names several warning signs. Others come from Google's spam policies and the FTC.

  • A guaranteed ranking. Google states that no one can guarantee a number one ranking, and that a promise of first place means you should go elsewhere. The same logic covers guaranteed leads, sales or mentions in AI tools.
  • A "special relationship" with Google. Google tells owners to be wary of claims of a special relationship or a "priority submit."
  • Secrecy. Google says to be cautious of a company that is secretive or will not clearly explain what it plans to do. You are responsible for what a company you hire does to your site, and deceptive work can get a site removed from Google's index.
  • Link buying or link schemes. Google's spam policies list buying or selling links for ranking purposes as link spam. Sites that break the policies may rank lower or not appear at all. Google's guide also says you should never have to link to your SEO.
  • Unsolicited emails. Google says to treat cold email from SEO firms with the same skepticism as obvious scams.
  • No account ownership. If the agency creates the ad account, analytics or website under its own login and keeps the keys, leaving gets hard. Treat this as a red flag even though Google's page does not use that wording.
  • Results claims with no evidence. The FTC's advertising guide for small business says advertisers need evidence for a claim before it runs. It also says endorsements should reflect typical results, and that "your results may vary" does not fix an atypical one. Ask what supports any number an agency quotes.

Questions to ask, and what a good answer sounds like

Google's list of interview questions covers previous work, following Google Search Essentials, expected results and timeframe, how success is measured, industry and local experience, time in business, and how you will communicate. Here is a version you can use on a call.

QuestionWhat a good answer sounds like
What exactly will you do each month?A written list of tasks, with what is not included. Not "we optimize your site."
Do you follow Google Search Essentials?Yes, and they can point to Google's documentation for the advice they give.
Can you guarantee rankings or leads?No. They explain what they can control and what they cannot.
How will you measure success?Agreed measures such as calls, form leads and tracked actions, plus honest limits on what can be attributed.
How long before I should expect movement?A range with reasons, not a date. SEO takes time and depends on your market.
Who owns the accounts, domain and data?You do, in your name, with the agency added as a user.
Will you tell me about every change and why?Yes. Google says an SEO with access to your server should explain every change.
Can I speak to past clients?Yes. Google suggests asking whether the work was useful, easy to work with and got positive results.
What do you ask me about my business?Questions about what makes you different, your competitors and how customers find you. Google says if they do not ask, find someone who does.
What happens if I stop?A clear exit: your accounts stay yours, and anything built is documented and handed over.

What to ask to see in a monthly report

A report should let you check the work without trusting the agency's word. Ask for:

  • What was done this month, in plain words, matched to the written scope.
  • The tracked results that matter to you: phone calls, form leads and similar actions, not only clicks or impressions.
  • Where those numbers came from, and what cannot be tracked. Phone calls and walk-ins often cannot be fully attributed.
  • What changed in your accounts and on your site, so you can see every edit.
  • For paid ads, how much was spent and where, in your own ad account.
  • What the agency plans next month, and why.
  • Read-only access to the source data, so you can check any figure yourself.

If a report is mostly a ranking screenshot for a few chosen phrases, ask what those rankings did for your business. If the agency also sells AI search work, read what AI search optimization is first, so you know what can and cannot be promised.

Contract terms to read before you sign

  • Scope in writing. Tasks, locations, number of pages or campaigns, and what is excluded.
  • Price and what it covers. Check for setup fees, and whether ad spend is billed separately. With Google Ads, ad spend should be paid directly to Google from your account. Our guide to Google Ads costs explains the difference between fees and spend.
  • Term and exit. Length of the starting term, how to cancel, and the notice required. Auto-renewals deserve a second read.
  • Ownership. Accounts, domains, analytics, content and data should be yours.
  • Access. Google lets an owner add and remove users in Search Console, and says verified owners can only be removed by taking away their verification from the site. Make sure you hold the owner role, and that you could revoke the agency's access without its help.
  • Reporting. How often, what is included, and who explains it.
  • Third-party costs. Tools, content or links that are billed on top.

How we would answer, as one honest example

You can use this section as a sample for comparison. It is not a claim that we are better than other agencies. Many good agencies will give similar answers.

  • Prices are published. SEO and AI search plans are $795, $1,795 and $2,895 a month. Google Ads management starts at $449 a month plus setup. See our pricing for what each includes.
  • Scopes are fixed in writing. You can see what is in and out before you sign.
  • You own your accounts and data. That includes ad accounts, domains and analytics.
  • We do not guarantee rankings, leads or AI mentions. We report real tracked results each month, including the limits of what can be attributed.
  • Three-month starting term, then month to month. The signed agreement sets the terms.
  • We reply to every inquiry within 2 business days.

Hold us to the same questions in the table. If an answer is vague, ask again.

A local option in Milwaukee and Southeast Wisconsin

If your business is in Kenosha, Milwaukee, Ozaukee, Racine, Washington or Waukesha county, the Wisconsin SBDC at UW-Milwaukee offers no-cost, confidential consulting and business education. Its site lists help with marketing. That could be a useful free second opinion on an agency proposal before you sign. As of November 2026 its listed phone number is (414) 227-3240; confirm hours and services on its site first.

For owners in the Chicago area, the same questions apply. The list above does not depend on where you are.

A short way to decide

Get at least two proposals and compare them against the same list. Ask for the scope in writing. Keep ownership of your accounts from day one. Start with a small, clear piece of work, and judge it on what was delivered and reported. If something goes wrong, the FTC takes complaints about deceptive business practices at ftc.gov or 1-877-FTC-HELP.

Quick answers

Can an SEO agency guarantee a first-page or number one ranking?

No. Google says no one can guarantee a number one ranking on Google, and that a promise of first place is a reason to go elsewhere. The same applies to leads and to mentions in AI answers.

Should I give an agency access to my Google accounts?

Yes, but in the right way. Keep your own account as the owner and add the agency as a user. Google's guidance for audits is to start with read-only access to Search Console, and owners can remove users at any time.

Do I need to hire an SEO at all?

Not always. Google says small local businesses can often do much of the work themselves, and recommends starting with its SEO Starter Guide. Hiring helps most when you lack time, or during a redesign or launch.

Where can I report a deceptive marketing company?

In the United States, Google points to the Federal Trade Commission at ftc.gov or 1-877-FTC-HELP. Free local advice is also available from the UW-Milwaukee Small Business Development Center if you are in its six-county area.

Sources

  1. Google Search Central: Do you need an SEO? Interview questions, red flags, read-only access, no guaranteed rankings, reporting to the FTC; checked Nov 2026
  2. Google Search Central: Spam policies Link spam and the consequences of violating the policies; checked Nov 2026
  3. Google Search Console Help: Users, owners and permissions Owner, full user and restricted user roles; owners can add and remove users; checked Nov 2026
  4. FTC: Advertising FAQ's: A Guide for Small Business Truthful ads, evidence for claims before they run, endorsements and typical results; checked Nov 2026
  5. Wisconsin SBDC at UW-Milwaukee No-cost, confidential consulting, including marketing, in six counties; checked Nov 2026

Keep reading

Not sure what you need?

Take the survey to find out exactly what your business needs.

Seven quick questions, about two minutes. We recommend a package and write your message for you. A person replies within 2 business days.

Take the survey
Ready when you are

Have something to grow?

Tell us what you are working on and where you want it to go.

We reply within 2 business days.

Say hello
↗